Discrete math: n pennies among k children with each child having atleast 2 pennies. This problem is posed in Lovasz's Discrete math book chapter 3 and I understand the correct answer which is ((n-k-1),(k-1))

Hayley Bernard

Hayley Bernard

Answered question

2022-07-17

Discrete math: n pennies among k children with each child having atleast 2 pennies
This problem is posed in Lovasz's Discrete math book chapter 3 and I understand the correct answer which is
( n k 1 k 1 )
However, why is my approach not right? Here it goes. We have n pennies. We group them into 2 each and hence have
n 2 units. Lets call them U. Now we have to distribute U units among k 1 children which will lead to
( n 2 2 2 k 1 )
ways. I subtracted 2 because 2 pennies will goto the first child.

Answer & Explanation

Ragazzonibw

Ragazzonibw

Beginner2022-07-18Added 15 answers

Step 1
You can see that your answer is wrong when different n give the same answer.
What you should do is give to each child 2 pennies.
You are left with n 2 k pennies and you want to give them to k children.
Can you take it from here?
Step 2
Recall that the number of ways to give m pennies to r children is
( m + r 1 r 1 ) .
Raynor2i

Raynor2i

Beginner2022-07-19Added 6 answers

Step 1
Assume you have n pennies, and you want to distribute them among k children, with each child having at least 2 pennies. You can go as follow:
Distribute 2 pennies to k child.
Since the pennies are identical, the order you distribute the pennies to the children does not matter.Then there is only one way to do that.
Now you left with n 2 K pennies.
Step 2
And the number of distributing the remaining pennies is:
( ( n 2 k ) + k 1 k 1 ) . [By the previous theorem in the textbook].
So the total number is:
(1) ( n k 1 k 1 )

Do you have a similar question?

Recalculate according to your conditions!

New Questions in Discrete math

Ask your question.
Get an expert answer.

Let our experts help you. Answer in as fast as 15 minutes.

Didn't find what you were looking for?