Prove that [G, N] <= N <=> N <= G

anon anon

anon anon

Answered question

2022-06-13

Answer & Explanation

madeleinejames20

madeleinejames20

Skilled2023-05-20Added 165 answers

To prove that [G,N]N if and only if NG, we need to show the two directions of the implication separately.
First, let's assume that [G,N]N. We want to prove that N is a normal subgroup of G.
To show that N is normal, we need to demonstrate that for every g in G, gNg1N.
Let g be an arbitrary element in G. Since [G,N]N, it follows that for every xG and nN, the commutator [x,n]=xnx1n1 is in N.
Now, consider an arbitrary element nN. We can rewrite n as [x,n]x1n1 for some xG. Since [x,n] is in N and N is a subgroup, we have [x,n]x1n1N.
Therefore, we have shown that for every gG, gNg1N, which proves that N is a normal subgroup of G.
Next, let's assume that N is a normal subgroup of G. We want to prove that [G,N]N.
To show this, we need to demonstrate that for every xG and nN, the commutator [x,n]=xnx1n1 is in N.
Since N is a normal subgroup of G, we have xnx1N for every xG and nN.
Let's consider an arbitrary xG and nN. Since N is a subgroup, n1N as well. Therefore, we have xnx1n1=(xnx1)n1N.
Hence, we have shown that for every xG and nN, [x,n]=xnx1n1N, which implies [G,N]N.
By proving both directions, we have established the equivalence: [G,N]N if and only if N is a normal subgroup of G.
To prove that [G,N]N if and only if NG, we will show the two directions of the implication separately.
First, assume that [G,N]N. We want to prove that N is a normal subgroup of G. To do this, we need to show that for every gG, gNg1N.
Let g be an arbitrary element in G. Since [G,N]N, it follows that for every xG and nN, [x,n]=xnx1n1N.
Consider an arbitrary element nN. We can express n as [x,n]x1n1 for some xG. Since [x,n]N and N is a subgroup, we have [x,n]x1n1N.
Therefore, for every gG, gNg1N, which proves that N is a normal subgroup of G.
Next, assume that N is a normal subgroup of G. We want to prove that [G,N]N. To show this, we need to demonstrate that for every xG and nN, [x,n]=xnx1n1N.
Since N is a normal subgroup of G, we have xnx1N for every xG and nN.
Consider an arbitrary xG and nN. Since N is a subgroup, n1N as well. Therefore, we have xnx1n1=(xnx1)n1N.
Hence, for every xG and nN, [x,n]=xnx1n1N, which implies [G,N]N.
By proving both directions, we have established the equivalence: [G,N]N if and only if N is a normal subgroup of G.

Do you have a similar question?

Recalculate according to your conditions!

Ask your question.
Get an expert answer.

Let our experts help you. Answer in as fast as 15 minutes.

Didn't find what you were looking for?