Magnetic force and frames of reference I'm having a hard time trying to understand the next situation: Suppose that I have a magnet that creates a quite uniform magnetic filed vec B in some direction. This is, in the frame of reference of the magnet, the particle is moving with velocity vec v in some direction. This is, in the frame of reference of the magnet, the particle is moving with velocity vec v and therefore the particle experiences a force given by: vec F=q (vec v xx vec B). This would cause the path of the particle to curve around the magnetic field. On the other hand, an observer situated in the particle would see the magnet moving with velocity vec v'=-vec v . How would this observer account for the movement of the magnet caused by the force F′? I believe that the force vec

Seamus Mcknight 2022-09-24 Answered
Magnetic force and frames of reference
I'm having a hard time trying to understand the next situation:
Suppose that I have a magnet that creates a quite uniform magnetic filed B . In the vicinity of this magnet there is a particle with charge q that is moving with velocity v in some direction.
This is, in the frame of reference of the magnet, the particle is moving with velocity v and therefore the particle experiences a force given by: F = q ( v × B ). This would cause the path of the particle to curve around the magnetic field.
On the other hand, an observer situated in the particle would see the magnet moving with velocity v = v . How would this observer account for the movement of the magnet caused by the force F ?
I believe that the force F is given by the relativistic transformation:
F = γ F
Knowing that the force is perpendicular to the velocity (this is if, for instance, the particle is moving along the x axis, then the force is along the y axis).
I am in the early stages of understanding relativistic mechanics so please forgive me is the question looks silly. Thanks in advance.
You can still ask an expert for help

Expert Community at Your Service

  • Live experts 24/7
  • Questions are typically answered in as fast as 30 minutes
  • Personalized clear answers
Learn more

Solve your problem for the price of one coffee

  • Available 24/7
  • Math expert for every subject
  • Pay only if we can solve it
Ask Question

Answers (1)

Ryan Underwood
Answered 2022-09-25 Author has 4 answers
There's an electric component to the Lorentz force:
F = q ( E + v × B )
In the frame of the particle where its velocity is zero, the force acting on the stationary particle would be interpreted as being electric, since the magnetic field B only acts on moving charge, and is given by:
F = q E
In your example, we can take v along x and B along z giving a F y along y so that the forces transform as :
F y = γ F y , q E y = γ q v × B z
And this is consistent with how the fields should transform, remembering that charge is a relativistic invariant where q = q
Did you like this example?
Subscribe for all access

Expert Community at Your Service

  • Live experts 24/7
  • Questions are typically answered in as fast as 30 minutes
  • Personalized clear answers
Learn more

You might be interested in

asked 2021-02-11

Resolve the force F2 into components acting along the u and v axes and determine the magnitudes of the components.
image

asked 2021-02-19

 
Two snowcats tow a housing unit to a new location at McMurdo Base, Antarctica, as shown in the figure. The sum of the forces FA and FB exerted on the unit by the horizontal cables is parallel to the line L, and FA=4200 N. Determine FB? Determine the magnitude of FA+FB?

asked 2021-01-06

A marble moves along the x-axis. The potential-energy functionis shown in Fig. 1
a) At which of the labeled x-coordinates is the force on the marble zero?
b) Which of the labeled x-coordinates is a position of stable equilibrium?
c) Which of the labeled x-coordinates is a position of unstable equilibrium?
image

asked 2021-02-25

A stream of water strikes a stationary turbine bladehorizontally, as the drawing illustrates. The incident water streamhas a velocity of +18.0 m/s, while the exiting water stream has avelocity of -18.0 m/s. The mass of water per second that strikesthe blade is 17.0 kg/s. Find themagnitude of the average force exerted on the water by theblade.

asked 2022-07-14
Magnetic force storage or amplification question
all forms of energy can be stored or amplified for example : capacitor , hydraulics ,laser , pulley , etc..
what is the equivalent to that for magnetic force ? can magnets be connected in series or parallel ?
asked 2022-05-13
Why are the electric force and magnetic force classified as electromagnetism?
I confuse the four kinds of fundamental interactions, so I think the electric force and magnetic force should not be classified as a big class called electromagnetism.
Here is my evidence:
1.The Gauss law of electric force is related to the surface integration but the Ampere's law corresponds with path integration.
2.The electric field can be caused by a single static charge while the magnetic force is caused by a moving charge or two moving infinitesimal current.
3.The electric field line is never closed, but the magnetic field line (except those to infinity) is a closed curve.
asked 2022-08-18
Why don't we simply define the magnetic field to point on the direction of magnetic force that acts on the moving charge?

New questions