Entropy change in a calorimetry problem A standard textbook problem has us calculate the change in

Govindennz34j 2022-05-14 Answered
Entropy change in a calorimetry problem
A standard textbook problem has us calculate the change in entropy in a system that undergoes some sort of heat exchange. For example, object A has specific heat c a and initial temperature T A and object B has specific heat c b with initial temperature T B . They are they put in contact with each other until they reach thermal equilibrium, and our goal is to find the total entropy change of the system.
The standard solution is to use
S = d Q T
where d Q = m c d T. But the above integral is only satisfied for reversible processes, whereas this heat exchange is clearly irreversible.
The usual workaround for this is to pick some reversible path and calculate the entropy change on our "fake" path, since entropy is a state variable. For example, in the free expansion of an ideal gas, we pick calculate the entropy change along an isotherm that carries us along the expansion to find the true change in entropy.
My question is - what exactly is the reversible path we are using when we use d Q = m c d T?
You can still ask an expert for help

Expert Community at Your Service

  • Live experts 24/7
  • Questions are typically answered in as fast as 30 minutes
  • Personalized clear answers
Learn more

Solve your problem for the price of one coffee

  • Available 24/7
  • Math expert for every subject
  • Pay only if we can solve it
Ask Question

Answers (1)

Lucille Melton
Answered 2022-05-15 Author has 18 answers
In calculating the entropy change for an irreversible process between two thermodynamic equilibrium states of a system, the first step in the procedure should always be to FORGET ALL ABOUT THE IRREVERSIBLE PROCESS PATH ENTIRELY. The entropy change can only be calculated for a reversible path between the same two end states.
Step 2: Identify a convenient reversible process path between the same two thermodynamic equilibrium states. Any reversible path will do, because they all give the same result for the entropy change.
Step 3: Calculate the integral of dQ/T for the reversible path you have identified. This is Δ S
For the example that you gave, I like use a process path where I start out by separating the two objects entirely, and then contacting each of them with a continuous sequence of constant temperature baths running from the original temperature of the object to its final equilibrium temperature. This gives me the integral that you alluded to in your question for each body.
For an irreversible process path, the temperature of the system is not even uniform spatially throughout, so what temperature do you use in evaluating the integral of dQ/T? Cauchy noted that, if you use the temperature at the boundary where the heat transfer is occurring (say for one of the bodies), you always find that the integral you get over the irreversible path is less than the entropy change of the body. This is called the Clausius inequality:
Δ S ( d Q / T ) B
where B signifies the boundary where the heat transfer is occurring.

We have step-by-step solutions for your answer!

Expert Community at Your Service

  • Live experts 24/7
  • Questions are typically answered in as fast as 30 minutes
  • Personalized clear answers
Learn more

You might be interested in

asked 2022-05-17
Calorimetry Problem
I was doing a problem in thermodynamics where the net heat is 0.
I don't understand why if you have say a copper calorimeter with water at say 15 °C and add a mass of copper at a higher temperature say 90 °C that when calculating the final temperature you would use for the copper piece this in the formula:
Q = m c ( T f T i )
Q = m c ( T f T i )
Where f is for final and i is for initial. Say mass is 0.3 kg. I was told that regarding T f T i I would need to use 90 T. This problem was to work out the final temperature of the system. Why was the initial 90 °C of the added copper substituted with T f in the heat equation?
asked 2022-05-07
How to derive the formula for heat produced due to electricity correctly from Joule's laws for heating?
From Joule's laws, we get this:
H I 2 R t
H = K I 2 R t . . . ( i )
Now, we have to find/define the value of K. According to my book, when 1 A of current passes through a conductor of 1 Ω for 1 s, 1 J heat is produced. If that's the case, then from ( i ) we get this:
1 = K × 1 × 1 × 1
K = 1
Therefore, we get our nice little formula:
H = K I 2 R t
My question with the above derivation is, how did we find that when 1 A of current passes through a conductor of 1 Ω for 1 s, 1 J heat is produced? Through experimentation? What was the name of the experiment and who conducted it?
asked 2022-04-07
What calorimetry approach is this?
Find the final tempertature of the system when 5 g m of steam at 100 C is mized with 31.5 g m ice at 20 C
Specific heat of ice and specific heat of steam is 0.5 c a l / g m / C
Specific heat of water is 1 c a l / g m / C
Latent heat of fusion is 80 c a l / g m
Latent heat of vaporization is 540 c a l / g m
My attempt:
I usually approach these problems by setting the final temperature as T. Then, I equate heat lost by steam to heat gained by ice. I have been taught this method and I am adept at it.
My problem: The solution given in my workbook is:
Heat released when 1 g of steam at 100 C is cooled to 20 C is 730 c a l. Now, this heat is given to be given to 1 + 6.3 g = 7.3 g of ice. This raises the temperature by 10 C
This is a new method for me, and I am unable to understand it. I wish to know:
How does this method work? In what calorimetry situations can this method be applied?
NOTE: The final answer is 10 C
asked 2022-05-15
Calorimetry - Emitted Joules
How can one calculate the total amount of emitted joules from an object with a temperature that isn't constant? A great start is this formula:
P = σ • A • (T^4)
If the formula is translated from sybmols to units it will look like this:
J/s = σ • (m^2) • (K^4)
(J/s) is joules emitted per second from an object. ( σ ) is the Stefan Boltzmann constant, 5.67•(10^−8). (m^2) is the area of the object. (K^4) is the temperature of the object, in Kelvin, to the power of 4. Now, if I transform the formula:
J = σ • (m^2) • (K^4) • s
Now one can get total amount of joules emitted ( J ) during a certain time ( s ), if one know the temperature and area. To the tricky part: what if the temperature isn't constant? The temperature will depend on how many joules that has already been emitted. And the joules that are being emitted will depend on the temperature.
How can I solve this? Do I need to combine this with an other formula?
Best regards! Please comment if something is unclear!
asked 2022-08-18
A temperature change of 20 C corresponds to a Fahrenheit temperature change of A) 68 F B) 36 F C) 18 F D) 11 F
asked 2022-07-15
Which material is a heat source for the other three materials?
Presented is a closed energy system containing equal masses of iron (55 degrees C), basalt (45 degrees C), and water (20 degrees C); air is 30 degrees C.
Which material is a heat source for the other three materials? 1) iron 2) basalt 3) air 4) water - Is the answer iron because it has the most heat?
During the first hour, the total energy in the system will 1) decrease, only 2) increase, only 3) decrease, then increase 4) remain the same - (Shouldn't it remain the same because of the conservation of energy?)
Also during the first hour, the temperature of the water will 1) decrease 2) increase 3) remain the same - (I think it will increase because it acts as a heat sink? Or maybe it will remain the same because water has the highest specific heat?)
Helping me understand one or all of these would be a great help!
asked 2022-05-09
Water equivalent of calorimeter
I am trying to solve numerical problem based on calorimetry. The water equivalent of a calorimeter is given in grams. But how is it possible as
w= mc and unit of m*c is Cal/°C.
where w= water equivalent
m= mass of the water
c= specific heat of water

New questions