Algebraic results with easier non-commutative proofs than commutative proofs (1) The dimension o

guringpw

guringpw

Answered question

2022-01-04

Algebraic results with easier non-commutative proofs than commutative proofs
(1) The dimension of a vector space over a field and the rank of a free module over a division ring.
(2) Theorem for C[x,y] and Theorem for the first Weyl algebra (it is not so difficult to show that in the commutative result we can replace C by any field of characteristic zero).

Answer & Explanation

Linda Birchfield

Linda Birchfield

Beginner2022-01-05Added 39 answers

If S is a set, then the free monoid S∗ on S is cancellative: That is, if a, b and c are three elements of S∗ satisfying either ac=bc or ca=cb, then a=b. This is almost trivial: The elements of S∗ are tuples of elements of S, and multiplication in S∗ is just concatenation of tuples; thus, ac=bc implies a=b by cutting off the last few entries, whereas ca=cb implies a=b by cutting off the first few entries.
If S is a set, then the free abelian monoid NS on S is cancellative. This is still not hard to prove, but less obvious. The elements of NS are formal N-linear combinations of elements of S or (equivalently) finite multisets of elements of S. In constructive logic, this becomes complicated to deal with, since equality may not be decidable in S; thus, a formal N-linear combination does not have well-defined multiplicities: e.g., if you have an N-linear combination x+y and you dont
amarantha41

amarantha41

Beginner2022-01-06Added 38 answers

The classification of Novikov algebras with non-abelian Lie algebras is much easier than the classification of Novikov algebras with abelian Lie algebras, i.e., in the commutative case

Do you have a similar question?

Recalculate according to your conditions!

New Questions in Commutative Algebra

Ask your question.
Get an expert answer.

Let our experts help you. Answer in as fast as 15 minutes.

Didn't find what you were looking for?